LICA Member Speaks Up at NYC Charter Revision Commission Hearing

On Monday April 19, the New York City Charter Review Commission held a public hearing at La Guardia Community College in Long Island City. Below is a portion of the testimony given by LICA member Dan Jacoby. A full videotaped record of the proceedings is also available at http://www.nyc.gov/html/charter/html/home/home.shtml

I will submit specific policy proposals later; tonight I want to focus on process. This charter is our city’s constitution, and therefore should not be changed for light or transient causes. Nor should it be changed without serious deliberation and open debate.

Unfortunately, any significant changes that you may propose in September will require us to vote on them without time for serious deliberation or sufficient debate. Two months isn’t long enough to sift through any substantial proposal, especially when most votersare focused on state and federal elections.

Questions abound regarding term limits, the Public Advocate, Borough Presidents, and Community Boards. But there is a lot more.

What about the budget process? Should the duties of the Administration for Children’s Services be changed, and if so, how? How should public complaints against the police department be handled? What about the appointment, and the practices, of the Board of Standards and Appeals? They have huge power to grant all sorts of variances, yet they are answerable only to the Mayor. Did you know that there is an “Art Commission” in the City Charter? These are but a few of the myriad issues that should be dealt with by this commission. You don’t have time, and we won’t have time to understand fully your recommendations for this year and make an informed decision in November.

There should be three criteria for any proposed change to go on this year’s ballot:

1. It should be simple and straightforward;

2. It should be unconnected to any other potential change; and

3. It should not be at all controversial.

In other words, it should be a no-brainer.

Two years ago, Mayor Bloomberg tried to push a congestion-pricing plan on us without time for full debate. His plan went down in flames; the same is likely to happen with anything you propose for this year’s ballot that does not meet those three criteria.

There is a better way. Submit your report after Thanksgiving, and we will have plenty of time to debate your recommendations openly. If necessary, a new commission can be appointed next year to amend your proposals whenever that open debate leads to a better solution.

Do this wrong, and your work is likely to go down in flames. Do it right, and your work will lead to a better city government, and a better city, for all of us.

Thank you.

About these ads

3 Responses to LICA Member Speaks Up at NYC Charter Revision Commission Hearing

  1. Randi says:

    Dan! What a thorough & purposeful testimony you presented.
    Any feedback? Updates?

  2. RoughAcres says:

    To paraphrase the President’s address to Wall Street (he said “unless your business is cheating people, this reform won’t hurt you”):

    Unless the Mayor’s intent is against the people’s best interests, transparency won’t hurt him. There may be urgent need for reform – so be it; be honest about why it is needed, how it will change things, and in what ways it will benefit the PEOPLE of New York.

    For example – it may save some money to eliminate the Public Advocate — but the PEOPLE will no longer have a City official whose entire reason for being is to protect the public’s interest. For me, that’s a net loss, despite saving some $.

    SLOW IT DOWN, Mayor Mike! Leave the CBs alone; they’re the equivalent of a town meeting, and – should you ever decide to attend them – a valuable lesson in democracy-in-action.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: